I went through a Sherlock Holmes phase as a teenager, during my first burst of anglophilia and being the kind of reader who loves the anti-hero, the outsider and INTJ characters in general. So, as you can see, Sherlock Holmes is a personal matter to me.
When BBC Sherlock 21st century came out last year I was a little annoyed. Not because of the 21 century setting, I’m ok with it, but for the name, Sherlock. How dare you address him by name? Who do you think he is? Your cousin? Moreover, while Martin Freemen could be potentially a perfect Dr. Watson, I considered Benedict Cumberbatch too conventionally handsome to portray Sherlock Holmes. Anyway, the trailer still looked quite cool, so I decided the series was worth a try.
Well, this is a good one. Martin Freemen is actually a perfect Watson, Benedict Cumberbatch is a fine actor and he definitely knows how to wear a coat. Most important, the chemistry is there. Lines and scenes from the literary work may be somewhat cheap, in their 21st century tv version, yet at the same time they strike me as honest and I daresay warm. Again, it’s personal matter to me. Now I’m jealous. Everyone can reach Sherlock Holmes, one Sherlock Holmes at least, without having to go though a teenage literary phase during a burst of anglophilia, provided that he or she is the kind of viewer who loves the anti-hero, the outsider or INTJ characters in general. In fact, I noticed there are already tons of fanficion out there. I’m not surprised at all, I first read my Jenkins nearly twenty years ago, I’m just a little jealous.
And there’s more. A big one. Cumberbatch reminds me of Withnail.
Each time he turns around, coat swirling, it’s Withnail I see, together with Sherlock Holmes, and my teenage years of anglophilia, a personal matter.

source